How about adding more statistics to the reviews? For example: I heard
SCC has a really big archive section, but is it bigger than the one at
IPT? People say the pretimes are better but about how much? And how well seeded are old torrents?
In my opionion a selection of random releases could be picked and the pretimes and number of seeds (or even the speed) could be compared. This would make it possible to actually rate trackers precisely and would help people to know which tracker they need faster.