Thread: posting ratio proofs and speedtest

I think all of that should be done privately by pm between the giver and the applicants coz posting ratio proofs so everyone can see them is a big risk for the giver and the people who are applying as there are alot of site representatives who are checking this forum and bisides this is open forum afterall so anyone can register.
To backup all i have said here is one exemple: (read the discussion)http://www.torrent-invites.com/chopp...e-members.html
But that is only my suggestion.
Anyone else agree or disagree with this please be free to reply.

eventhough i agree to the above somewhat....posting the ratio proof openly helps in finding cheaters by others. it makes one think before posting proofs openly.

well cons and pros r there :)

I don't think it was ratio proofs or speedtests that ultimately led to poor PaNeKoTa losing his account. I suspect it was other identifying features in that thread such as the fact that 3 of 4 invitees got banned, one of them for trading, which gave the x264 spy enough info to determine which account was PaNeKoTa's. The really sad thing is, if he had avoided the chopping block altogether and sent that info to the mods privately I suspect he'd probably still have his x264 account.

This forum is designed so that you can register an account but you can't send pms until after you're repped in and become a full member. So there would be that logistical problem to work around.

But I don't support this idea because I know how many cheaters/dupes are caught by their ratio proofs and speedtests. But this tells the story: Torrent Invites! Get your free private torrent tracker invites ! - Banned Users